The Ethics of Dark Patterns: When Persuasive Design Crosses a Line

“The consumer is not a moron. She is your wife.”

So said advertising genius David Ogilvy. His advice? Treat your customers like you would your own family. Give them respect. Be honest with them. Have their best interests at heart.

But somewhere along the way, business practices have crossed an ethical line. Dark patterns in design deliberately manipulate users against their will and best interests. They exploit human psychology to trick and deceive.

What if your wife came home one day feeling betrayed and used by a company? As business owners, we have a moral responsibility to build trust with customers. Dark patterns erode that trust. Let’s explore why.

‍

The Broken Trust Fall

Imagine this: you sign up for a free trial with an online company. A few days later, you start seeing unexpected charges. You try to cancel, only to discover an impossible maze of menus and forms. You contact customer service, growing increasingly frustrated. “Just cancel it!” you insist, only to be funnelled into more upsell offers.

This strategy is called a “roach motel”—easy to enter, impossible to escape. It preys on human psychology, trapping users into staying with a service they don’t want. The company profits: the customer suffers. This erodes trust in brands and leaves people feeling used.

Persuasion has its place, but deception destroys relationships. Consider the story of Wells Fargo opening fake accounts for millions of customers. Their stock dropped, lawsuits piled up, and their reputation was sullied for years. Manipulation works in the short term but kills loyalty in the long term.

Are you willing to throw trust and loyalty out the window for a quick buck? Let’s see why that’s a dangerous game to play.

‍

When “Persuasion” Becomes Manipulation

What exactly is the difference between ethical persuasion and manipulation? Persuasion guides users towards a mutually beneficial action. Manipulation deceives users into taking an action that primarily benefits the company.

Let’s compare examples:

Persuasion

Product tours that highlight new features

Manipulation

Pre-checked boxes to add items to shopping carts

Persuasion

Recommending relevant products

Manipulation

Making it easy to sign up, hard to cancel  

Persuasion

Showing how a service can help solve a problem                        

Manipulation

Charging unexpected fees at checkout

The critical difference is choice and control. Ethical persuasion gives users the freedom to evaluate options and decide for themselves. Manipulation limits user choice through deception, restriction of information, or coercion and erodes agency and autonomy.

‍

The Dark Arts of Manipulation

But isn’t all marketing meant to persuade people somehow? True, but ethical persuasion is mutually beneficial, while manipulation advantages the company at the user’s expense.

Let’s explore some common dark pattern techniques:

Forced Continuity

This automatically renews subscriptions without consent through pre-checked boxes or confusing settings. The goal is to trap users in commitments they didn’t actively choose. Forced continuity strips away user control through deception and friction.

Roach Motel

Roach Motels makes signing up easy and extremely difficult to cancel. Companies create obstacle courses of menus, confusing settings, and repetitive confirmation screens to prevent users from leaving. This restrictive design locks in revenue through frustration and exhaustion.

Sneaking

Ever notice strange extras in your shopping cart that you didn’t add? Sneaking is the practice of defaulting users into purchases – like pre-checked boxes for extra warranties. This drives up order values but decreases trust in the process. If users feel duped, they churn.

Confirmshaming

“No thanks; I don’t want to save money.” Confirmshaming uses insulting language to pressure users into opting in. It implies that they must be stupid to say no. This is emotional blackmail, not ethical consent.

Hidden Costs

You arrive at checkout only to find new fees you weren’t expecting. Hidden costs are revealed late in the purchase process to prevent abandonment. But this still erodes trust and infuriates customers. Just read the reviews for travel sites that do this when booking.

The Line In The Sand

These dark pattern techniques restrict user autonomy through deception, confusion, and frustration. Customers feel cheated and used, destroying loyalty. Meanwhile, the company temporarily profits through duplicity. That may work short-term but implodes long-term relationships. Is it worth the tradeoff?

As we’ve discussed, the line comes down to choice. Ethical persuasion gives clear options and recommendations without limiting decisions. Manipulation restricts user control on purpose, often secretly. And that crosses the line into exploitation.

Notice how these patterns limit user control through deception, friction, and emotional manipulation. They abuse human psychology to boost conversions at the expense of user experience. This detonates trust.

‍

The Ethical Line in The Sand

So, where should we draw the line on persuasion? As marketing wizard David Ogilvy would say, treat your customers like your own family. Build trust through honesty. Have their best interests at heart. Back up claims with proof. And give unambiguous, informed choices.

Manipulation erodes trust. Honest persuasion earns loyalty.

So be straight with customers about:

• Benefits and costs: Don’t hide fees. Highlight how your product helps.

• Commitments and continuity: Allow users control without friction or tricks.

• User data and privacy: Be transparent about how data is used.

In other words, don’t treat customers like lab rats to exploit. Treat them like trusted partners in shared success because manipulation yields short-term gains but destroys long-term customer lifetime value.

“You can’t build a great brand on short-term thinking.” - David Ogilvy

The legacy you build is more important than this week’s conversions. So stay far away from anything that could be construed as dirty tricks. Be transparent. Go above and beyond for customers. Build an exceptional experience worthy of trust and loyalty. That’s how you turn customers into fans.

‍

Bottle The Magic Of Trust

David Ogilvy was a master of crafting human connections through storytelling. People don’t just buy products; they buy relationships, beliefs, and feelings. We have a chance to give them a sense of respect and partnership. So don’t squander that opportunity through deception.

What if you made trust your competitive advantage? Prioritized transparency and customer care above all else? Treated your customers better than anyone else does? Perhaps no short-term tactic could compete with that kind of brand loyalty and goodwill.

“If you tell the truth about your product and treat your customers with respect, they’ll return the favour.” - David Ogilvy.

So don’t get lost in short-term tactics. Create lifelong customer relationships built on trust. Keep user needs above your own. Have integrity always. That’s how you build a brand that stands the test of time.

The choice is ours. Do we manipulate and mislead? Or serve and guide? Customers will reward those who respect them. So take a stand for trust today—and reap loyal advocates for decades to come.

‍